Charles B. Haley (1893)
Samuel R. Rice (1894-1899)*
Walter A. Hill (1912-1932)*
Harry J. Ainsworth (1932-1947)*
Francis S. Hoban (1947-1948)**
Paul J. Lynch (1948-1979)
Bobby N. Stewart (1979-2001)
Bernard P. Nally (2001-2004)
Robert H. Spencer (2004-2005)
Michael R. Begonis (2005-2019)
Joseph Desmond (2019 – 2025)
Brian Pupa (2025 – current)